1-The
CHS tracking approach has failed. The
CHS Principal and Department Heads all agree that it has failed and the results are that more than 1/3 of the CHS students are not proficient and classes are segregated by race.
2-The decisions on which level to place a student in College Prep or Enriched cannot be clearly articulated and are without foundation says the
CHS Science Department Head, many parents and teachers.
3-There is a dramatic increase in low achievement by students as the amount of tracking increases from elementary to high school. Students are overwhelming proficient where tracking is least in the elementary schools and dramatically less by
CHS.
4-Similar African American students are achieving at over 60% proficiency at the
Abington High School compared to barely 33% proficiency at
CHS.
Abington High eliminated tracking.
5-Low tracking leads to low expectations of students, and a label of low ability leads to low motivation of students.
6-Overcoming the institutional push down of students is extremely difficult and rare for parents, teachers and students. A high school student in 2007 said that he and his family were "
silenced" by the tracking. A high school student in 2008 said that the kids at the lower level feel "dumb" beginning in 3rd grade.
7-The parent who supports a kid to become proficient in elementary school is the same parent with the same kid who is not proficient in 11
th grade. Parents should not be required to create student success against the odds in
Cheltenham. Instead the schools should make academic achievement the universal standard, not an "opportunity".
8-
Discipline incidents rise with bored and distracted students and decline with engaged and challenged students. Once kids are placed in difficult classes where they are expected to achieve the discipline incidents generally decrease.
9-Hard working students with average ability can achieve at the highest levels of
CHS including the College Board Advanced Placement level.
10-Many students, parents, teachers, schools and community members are currently suffering from a low achievement lie that has been made plain by our
Abington neighbor. The problem is not primarily the students or the parents. Tracking is dumbing down the children.